Analysis

Odd Meters by the Numbers: How 5/4 and 7/4 Divide the Bar

How many ways can you split five or seven beats, and why jazz players count them in twos and threes.

Take Five is in 5/4. Paul Desmond wrote it, and the Dave Brubeck Quartet recorded it for the 1959 album Time Out. Most players who learn it never count to five. They count a group of three and a group of two, and that is the whole trick. This page puts numbers on why, and gives you code to try other bar lengths.

The rule: groups of two and three

An odd meter is a bar with an odd number of beats that cannot split evenly. Five beats will not halve. So musicians cut the bar into small groups, and the groups are almost always two beats or three beats long. A group of two feels like a step. A group of three feels like a skip. Mix them and the bar has a limp that repeats.

For 5/4 there are only two ways to do it, 3+2 and 2+3. For 7/4 there are three: 2+2+3, 2+3+2 and 3+2+2. Each way puts the accents in different places, so the same seven beats can feel like three different bars.

Count the ways with code

This short Python function lists every way to split a bar into groups of two and three, in order.

from functools import lru_cache

@lru_cache(None)
def groupings(n, parts=(2, 3)):
    """All ways to split n beats into groups of 2 or 3, in order."""
    if n == 0:
        return [()]
    out = []
    for p in parts:
        if p <= n:
            out += [(p,) + rest for rest in groupings(n - p, parts)]
    return out

for n in range(2, 13):
    print(n, len(groupings(n)))

Running it gives the number of groupings for each bar length.

Beats in the barWays to group it
21
31
41
52
62
73
84
95
107
119
1212

The count grows slowly at first and then faster. Seven beats have three groupings, and ten beats already have seven. The number of possible shapes keeps growing with the bar length, which is one reason longer bars take more rehearsal to agree on.

What the groupings sound like

Mark the first beat of each group with an X and the rest with a dot, and the accent pattern shows up on the page.

def accents(groups):
    out = []
    for g in groups:
        out += ["X"] + ["."] * (g - 1)
    return " ".join(out)

Here is the output for the five groupings of 5/4 and 7/4.

3+2    X . . X .
2+3    X . X . .
2+2+3  X . X . X . .
2+3+2  X . X . . X .
3+2+2  X . . X . X .

Play any line against a metronome that clicks every beat and tap only the X marks. In 3+2 the long group comes first, so the bar feels like it leans forward and resolves. In 2+3 the long group comes last, so the bar feels like it is gathering weight. Take Five is usually counted as 3+2, which is why it has a rocking, forward lean.

How long is the bar?

A 5/4 bar is longer than a 4/4 bar at the same tempo, and that changes how a phrase fits. Here are bar lengths in seconds for a quarter note pulse.

Quarter notes per minute4/4 bar5/4 bar7/4 bar
1002.40 s3.00 s4.20 s
1401.71 s2.14 s3.00 s
1801.33 s1.67 s2.33 s

At 140 a 7/4 bar lasts exactly 3.00 seconds. A four bar phrase in 7/4 takes 12 seconds, and a four bar phrase in 4/4 at the same tempo takes less than 7. If you play a line you wrote in 4/4, it will not simply fit into 5/4. The line needs to be rebuilt around the new bar, and this is the hardest part of writing in odd meters.

A practice routine

  1. Pick a grouping, say 3+2. Clap the X beats while a metronome clicks every beat.
  2. Play one note per beat on a single string until the accents feel automatic.
  3. Play a scale and accent only the X beats.
  4. Switch to 2+3 and notice that the same notes feel like a different bar.
  5. Move to 7/4 and try all three groupings, one at a time.

Spend a few minutes on each grouping before moving on.